Parliament is supposed to be paramount. But since the introduction of the Charter in 1982, the Supreme Court has come to rival Parliament as the ultimate lawmaking authority, increasingly overturning legislation it deems bad policy. Supreme Errors is a new series by the National Post dedicated to 10 of the worst Supreme Court decisions since 1982. In this installment, Queen’s Law professor Bruce Pardy discusses 2020’s Fraser v. Canada ruling.
By Bruce Pardy, published by the National Post on November 19, 2026
Once upon a time, being a Mountie was a full-time job. The RCMP had no part-time members. But in 1997, the Mounties created a job-sharing program to provide more flexible working arrangements, especially for their female officers. The program was voluntary and open to everyone. Most who chose to enroll were women with children. In 2020, the Supreme Court of Canada declared the program unconstitutional. It was advantageous to women. It just wasn’t advantageous enough. [Continue reading at the publisher’s website here]
In Brief
In Fraser v. Canada, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the RCMP’s job-sharing program violated s. 15(1) of the Charter. Although the program applied identical contribution and benefit rules to all participants—pensions being strictly proportional to hours worked, with a buy-back option available only for unpaid leave—the majority found adverse-impact discrimination.
In Fraser and the line of cases descending from Andrews v. Law Society of British Columbia (1989), Prof. Pardy argues that the Supreme Court of Canada has rewritten s. 15(1) of the Charter so that it no longer guarantees equal treatment under neutral rules but instead requires equality of outcome (equity). In his view, the Court treats a seemingly neutral, voluntary program as unconstitutional whenever members of a protected group make different choices that produce different results, on the ground that those choices are themselves shaped by systemic inequality. The outcome: the state is required to put them in a better position than everyone else under the plan, even if the state did not create the disadvantage and even when the government has chosen not to exercise the optional power in 15(2).
Bruce Pardy is executive director of Rights Probe and professor of law at Queen’s University.
Contact us to book Bruce Pardy for an interview or appearance, or to subscribe to our newsletter: rightsprobe@protonmail.com.